Jun 30, 2011
The Chicago Tribune wants to hold Whittier parents to account for the costs of delaying a new library at the Pilsen elementary school.
There’s another way of looking at it. You could also hold CPS leadership to account for commencing the project in a manner that seemed designed to foment a confrontation.
You might even ask about contracts being let before the Board of Education approved the project.
And it would be interesting to get a breakdown of the $150,000 that CPS officials claim as the cost of the construction delay – quite arguably due to their mismanagement of a delicate situation.
Gapers Block has its own questions.
One central fact is disputed. The Tribune is incorrect in reporting that there was an agreement to build the library inside the school, Whittier Parents Committee organizers say.
As Newstips reported yesterday, they maintain that negotiations were cut off when Ron Huberman resigned as CPS chief last year, before the parents committee’s proposal could be considered. (As the Tribune reports, they have videotapes of the meetings; they say these back them up.)
Aside from that, the Tribune employs a good bit of innuendo (and a bit of red-baiting) suggesting the Whittier parents are dupes.
There’s a dark, vague allusion to the past involvement of two activists with the Pilsen Alliance (which is actually a well-regarded organization, now mainly focused on environmental issues). This is curious, since it fails to mention that Whittier was a community school, with Pilsen Alliance as its community partner. Funding for the partnership came through CPS. That meant ESL and GED classes, along with a women’s economic development project.
There’s a strange reference to a ten-room expansion the parents supposedly “wanted,” which would supposedly cost $1.5 million. That never happened, said Alejandra Ibanez, former executive director of the Pilsen Alliance and program director at the Oak Park River Forest Community Foundation since 2010.
There was a brainstorming session with UIC architecture students where a three-classroom smaller expansion was one of many ideas, but it was never presented to CPS, she said. It was never costed out, either, she said.
There’s an odd treatment of Ald. Danny Solis’s allocation of TIF funds for building improvements. The Tribune says “the group appealed to Solis, who allocated $1.7 million in TIF funds.”
“That was a seven-year fight,” says Ibanez. Solis finally agreed in 2009 – he actually allocated $1.4 million — at a time when he was getting additional heat from community outrage after CPS turned over the De La Cruz Middle School building to charter school operated by UNO, which Solis founded. (De La Cruz students were sent to Whittier.)
None of this is in the Tribune’s account, which pretty clearly sets forth the version of events that CPS brass prefers.
Ibanez said she finds insulting the notion that the Whittier parents are being manipulated. “There’s always been a strong core of parents,” she said. “They’ve been incredibly consistent all the way through. They have always been the leaders there.”
It was the parents who insisted on maintaining the school’s fieldhouse, she said.
“It’s typical” of a certain mindset “to see loud brown women” and assume “they must not know any better; they must be being led astray.”
Finley Peter Dunne notwithstanding, a lot of journalism serves to comfort the comfortable and afflict the afflicted. By such lights, something is just not right when people who are supposed to be powerless come together and demand to be heard.